Any bad experiences?

topic posted Thu, May 19, 2005 - 3:46 PM by  Siren
Share/Save/Bookmark
Advertisement
I just applied to the Peace Corps and a friend warned me that I should do my homework first. He said that he had heard negative things about the Peace Corps. However I have traveled the earth extensivly and have never, ever met a Peace Corps Volunteer (PCV) that has disliked what they do. Every PCV has only raved about their ecperience.

Can anyone here shed light on the negative side?

Thank you in advance.
posted by:
Siren
Puerto Rico
Advertisement
Advertisement
  • Re: Any bad experiences?

    Wed, May 25, 2005 - 11:53 AM
    I think I was the 6th person in my 25-person training group to leave service early. I am surprised you have never heard of bad PC experiences, as I believe it is quite common. However, I do not regret joining the Peace Corps (or leaving) and feel that the experience altered my life in a positive way, in the end.

    Basically I was unhappy with my living situation, especially living with another PC volunteer who did not seem to want me there. The work was often frustrating; as a health volunteer I had to create my own projects and try to change people's lifestyles. Hard to do! But the biggest problem for me was being isolated and being somewhat thwarted in trying to make friends by the situation with the other PCV. I wish I had handled things differently with her, but in the end decided that my misery was not helping anyone, so I came home.

    Peace Corps totally changed my life for the better, even if the actual experience (and recovery period) were very difficult.
    • Re: Any bad experiences?

      Thu, May 26, 2005 - 2:05 AM
      I am not quite sure what I was looking for as responses to my question.

      I guess I have heard minor bad things but nothing that would keep me from joining. MOst seem to be specific situations like yours. YOu were the sixth in your training group. WOw that is not a good record and you probably were not the last.

      THat is weird that you had a roomate. I have not heard that one.

      I was in Malawi DEc 2004 to MArch 2005 and I met a lot of PEace COrps people. ONe girl was kicked out and I don't remeber why but she still liked the PEace Corps.

      Anyway I think my mind is now made up. THere is not enough negative resons and tons of positive reasons for me to join.
      • PC Namibia 01-03

        Thu, February 9, 2006 - 2:46 PM
        we starte
        • Re: PC Namibia 01-03

          Thu, February 9, 2006 - 2:54 PM
          Stupid computer went forward before i was ready... sorry...
          anywho...

          We started with 17 and left with 8 (about that anyway) MANY other groups in PC namibia had HUGE drop out rates. a few sent for medical reasons. one sent for admin reasons but that guy won his case and it was all cleared up...

          Anywho- A lot of people had a LOT of problems. mostly with placement. and well... its the government and its Peace Corps. its isolating. its borring. its hard. there is sexual harassment and corporal punishment. there is AIDS, there is feeling very alone a crowd. there are bad house mates. getting forgotten in your village and locked in the hostel for a weekend. there is adultry and drama that you get dragged into. you live in a fish bowl where everyone stares at you ALLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL the time. i mean all the time. there is alcoholism and std's among PCV's/
          There are a mirad of other things like food/water/housing/toileting/traveling problems.

          I loved my peace corps experiance. including all of these things. seriously.
          Some people don't love it and leave. some people count the days till it over. some people have to be dragged away- and still stay and work (i lived there till 2005.)
          anywho. just be realistic. its no picnic. but it can be rewarding. and if you find yourself beating your head against that government wall SO much and still getting robbed blind by your village and sexually harrassed in your home on a daily basis... its ok to walk away and find something else that will work.

          !gai se na i re.
          trish
          • Re: PC Namibia 01-03

            Thu, April 5, 2007 - 12:39 PM
            trish, how was your experience as a white woman in south africa?

            i'm about to begin my application process and plan to put Africa down as my region of preference.
            you've mentioned sexual harassment ,and corporal punishment...care to expand?
            at any point did you feel very threatened?

            also, how are the responses to your being a white woman and having dreads?

            thank you for any info you're wiling to provide

            peace
            niki
            • Re: PC Namibia 01-03

              Sun, May 27, 2007 - 12:48 AM
              good question. sorry i never saw it sooner...

              (future reference, cc me for a response as I don't check these kindof tribes often.)

              but to answer the question:

              I was in a Post Aparthied society. sometimes it was tough. most of the time i definately felt like I was experiancing the "fish bowl" effect - where you are stared at all the time. And sometimes I use to pretend I must have a cartoon banner running over my head that everyone was reading because they would state what I was doing all the time and know my outfits and hair styles more closely than I did. people watched me. carefully. children were like little boy band fans around me at times. mean at others. Some people would not speak to me unless I spoke Damara and some would only see me and want money. And luckily I had a lot of friends of various backgrounds.

              About the sexual harassment- the best peice of advice i can give on that - and this is my general rule - pc or not- confront it head on, directly, and with humor and style and grace. Humility is the best way to put a stop to it. And never let it really truely bug you... it helps to make friends with ghe big boys as well.
              ok ONE night I had some dude come knocking when he knew I was home alone. I did NOT let him in. And never feel like you can't tell a guy off. don't be too overly culturally sensitive- you also deserve for others to be culturally sensitive to you.

              about the corporal punishment- yes it happens. with great frequency and in sometimes the most horrific ways. Police officers having sex with minors in a school happens. tourist sex trade happens. small homeless boys being bought and sold at alarming rates... happens. And you meet all of these kids and then some. Kids will come to you for help. they will (if your very very lucky) trust you as that one salvation. Thats a huge responsibilty and burden to bear but - without you... what? then what? then who? someone- yes- maybe- but to have that kid come to you in the middle of the night bleeding- or to sneak a badly written completely crushed scrap of paper with a note into your purse - or to have their little sisters come and tell you - or to actually witness some horrific beating of a child... these things have happened to me-

              but only because i was THERE. and i was really fully there with people and able to witness and help and understand and sometimes fix. You will come up with your own answers to whatever some REAL life has to hand you. I can only say- be flexible, open, and concientious of not only your imeadiate response and its effects but thinking in the LONG term and the rippling effect it has on so many people long after you are gone.

              about the dreads- I didn't have them till after PC- but i can tell you my sista rachel up in the north of Namibia had more than rave reviews on it and i got mine after living there 5 years- people don't think much differently than they do here about them- other than just being more use to seeing them. being a white girl with dreads is more unique but not unheard of.

              hope i'm not too late for some advice to reach you. hope it helps anyone else as well.

              peace corps is a beautiful experiance and i wouldn't trade it for anything.

              1 luv, trish
              • Dan
                Dan
                offline 0

                Re: PC Namibia 01-03

                Sun, May 27, 2007 - 6:41 AM
                I was a volunteer over 20 years ago in Honduras. Yes, It felt like living in a fishbowl but I wouldn't trade it for anything. As a 7th grade teacher, I also feel like living in a fishbowl for not so obvious reasons.
                • Re: PC Namibia 01-03

                  Sun, May 27, 2007 - 12:10 PM
                  yes... the truth is i got VERY depressed ... which i believe was a combonation of isolation (nearest volunteer 5 hrs away, plus i had to lock myself in my house at sunset everynight due to cultural practices) PLUS the malaria profalxis i was taking (meflaquoin- do tons of research before you agree to take this powerful medicine) .... = miserable ... and the PC admin refused to transfer me to a different post (this was Cameroon 2002)
                  • This is the maximum depth. Additional responses will not be threaded.

                    Re: PC Namibia 01-03

                    Mon, May 28, 2007 - 10:34 AM
                    what brooklyn said - a LOT of that happened to a LOT of PCV's in Namibia as well.
                    • Re: PC Namibia 01-03

                      Fri, June 1, 2007 - 3:07 PM
                      what did? having to stay in at night? being stared at?
                      my interviewrer likened the experience as that of a "rockstar," like PCV's are a novelty item to the host country natiomals.

                      thanks for the insight
                      • Re: PC Namibia 01-03

                        Fri, June 1, 2007 - 7:09 PM
                        the being stared at. all the time. everywhere. being "famous" is NOT all it is cracked up to be. you'll see. :) maybe. but every single pcv experiance is different. and there are big cities in africa- lots of volunteers picture mud huts for 2 years and land in a ghetto apartment on min. wage teaching ungrateful and unruly city kids and eating at KFC for lunch. You NEVER know! but really- the staring rarely stops in africa. :) but ... i have to say - one of my greatest friends - she was in a very rual area- had dreads and a very down to earth way about her- she didn't so much get treated any better- but maybe due to her nature as well- she was just blending and connecting better than some other PCV's.

                        shutting yourself in at night- i have heard some cultures are definate about certain practices after dark. lots of superstition with night and lots of interesting do's and don'ts in most any culture. (durring aparthied they had curfew and so the aftermath of that in my area was just a long standing habit of Not going out at night- but i'm trying NOT to overgeneralize. its a big place... a BIG BIG place... areas differ drastically)

                        One thing I have to mention that kindof makes me laugh a bit and wonder in a way- the friends a PCV makes... what that group is composed of... how integrated ARE some volunteers. I use to think there were kindof 3 kinds of volunteers:
                        * The ones that have ONLY friends that are PCV's and just kinda "know" the folks in the village.- they are in the capitol ever weekend or hanging out at their friend's village. They like to be on every committee and group so that they have a chance to see more americans. They are dating the VSO in the village over. Mostly they have a lot of hang ups about the folks they work with such as, "They have no idea what i gave up to come here!" "They don't really want me or know what I can Do for Them!?" Also a bit co-dependant on PC and whine about the situation quite a lot. lots of avoidance behaviors. sometimes alcoholism.

                        * The ones that have ONLY "host country nationals" as their friends. They kindof know the names of the other volunteers in the area but you never see them. ever. maybe at a meeting. When you do run into them in the capitol and they are chilling with their very cool and definately "cultural" friends - (who are curious about you and not disinterested in having you join the conversation...but...) The culurally elite shun you after hello's or even look at you like, "Who do you think You are- I am Being Cultural! Do Not Inturrupt me while I'm communing and absorbing culture." They also try to do EVERYTHING on their own. (thus failing at really getting big things done cuz they spend 2 years recreating things other volunteers have already done, failed, succeeded at or worked the kinks out of.- NEVER just jump into a project. always find out if someone tried that before- and find out why it did or didn't work... make it BETTER. don't Make the SAME MISTAKES! - ok off that soap box.)

                        *The PCV's who have a bit of both worlds. They have lots of PCV friends, go to all the meetings, invite others to their village to hang out and see their family (or in my case- my house was the vacation spot! it was the shit. still rual but i really had a great set up- cable tv, running water, phone, internet, wildlife, a great bar and pool table, hikable tourist spots, access to groceries and a post office and a clinic. etc... so ya- LOTS and LOTS of PCV's landed - (sometimes stranded) into my village and the local people of Kamanjab would just bring them to my house. would assume they would come stay with me. I met a lot of really awesome people this way as well!- not always PCV's. - throw a rock in some areas of Africa and you'll hit a volunteer.
                        --- The PCV's that integrate into the local culture will be able to go out into the "ghetto" At NIGHT and be totally safe because they have a group of friends to aid support and acknowledgement that - this person is "one of them" - a PCV that is integrated makes friends so closely with the teachers that they will come to her/him and confide things you would never expect- BECAUSE you are not just a volunteer but a Friend.

                        HIV / Aids teaching is NOT something you can do without being Friends and being a Peer that is listened to and respected. You just can't expect people to open up with questions about sex with someone who is so very different and disconnected from them.

                        I just wanted to interject this somewhere because it is definately something that struck me as the core of a successful or unsuccessful volunteer. How they relate to people as JUST People without all the Peace Corps "stuff". (cuz you are being trained by the US government to go "develop" a nation. just think about that a min and how we really define "development". )

                        Just- GO- have fun! (firstly! cuz its a grand adventure- all of it... life in general- peace corps is just a bump in time compaired to everything but its some really intense and sometimes borring time... take books...) AND- go meet people, go connect, go help where you can and don't cause more harm. You will have a GREAT TIME!

                        AND - if Peace Corps- starts Dicking you around- cuz it is the US Gov't. - IF they really start to f- with you and don't listen- MAKE THEM! they DO have some accountability and don't think that you can't demand some things if they really f you up- (cuz really- the most negitive things i've ever heard - are because of Peace Corps buracracy and upper management decisions.- you can deal with it though. be Savy girl! be smart- talk the talk- pay attention to the rules - so you know how to break and which ones to break and when and you know how to protect yourself and what you can expect from them. READ YOUR PC MANUAL! REALLY READ that Guide Book! seriously! i used mine quite a lot- many of us did.)

                        ok... i actually have a real job that i'm not doing right now so i better stop dreaming and teaching about pc life.

                        (folks might wonder why i'm being such a "know it all" - i trained more than 15 groups. I also was called on to solve a lot of PCV problems both durring and after PC. I was also able to see more than 200 volunteers come and go because i was living there for years after PC. SO... i kindof got to know the PC way of life pretty well. :) - loved a lot of it!)

                        I just met a pcv that is leaving next week for the Gambia. he works in one of my houses that i manage now. Its been exciting helping him prepare! (so i guess i'm just all a-buzz with that for the moment.)

                        1 luv, trish
  • Re: Any bad experiences?

    Fri, December 21, 2007 - 3:04 PM
    Peace Corps service is hard. You will be challenged on every level of your being. You will come face to face with yourself and your strengths and weaknesses. I was in Bangladesh from 2005 to 2006. During that time half of my group quit and left for various reasons. I myself pondered leaving MANY times. In addition to the "fishbowl" feeling, the horrible sexual harrassment, the brutal punishments of officials and those in authority to those who had no power; I was threatened sexually by my sitemate and had a situation where I was placed in a hidden safe house in the capital until Peace Corps got him out of the country. Later Islamic militants began bombing our schools and many of us were forced into lockdown into our homes. Eventually we were evacuated and given 3 hours to get out of the country and the program was shut down. Through all of THAT I stayed. I loved the school that I taught at. I loved my girls. I loved my village. I regret none of it. Yes it is a bureaucracy and yes the countries that PC operates in are incredibly difficult but each experience is different. Overall i believe the mission of Peace Corps is a good one. And I believe that you will make what you will of the experience. It will be all your own. Some people left Bangladesh hating it. I could of too but it has shaped me in ways that I am just beginning to understand.

    Good luck on your journey!!

    Maya
  • Unsu...
     

    Re: Any bad experiences?

    Tue, April 8, 2008 - 5:20 PM
    HI Siren,

    I saw your post and wanted to respond. I am going to cut and paste some from an earlier response I left. Here it is:

    "I was a Peace Corps Volunteer in Bulgaria 98-00 and I ran their recruiting campaigns in southern Cal for nearly three years as well so I know quite a bit and would be happy to talk with you in much more detail about your questions. You can email me and we could talk by phone in more detail. I've had to interview many, amny people for positions stayed in touch with a fair amount after they went over and having worked on both sides of things as a PCV and employee, I think I can be helpful to you. Feel free to send me a personal email as your questions are important and I remember having the same ones before I made the decision. I'll be happy to give you the full scoop, the good and the ugly. All in all though, for me, it was one of the most extraordinary experiences of my life. In my case, I felt PCorps was extremely well run. However, I also know that experiences vary widely on a wide range of factors- who is in charge in your country, particulars about your specific site placement following training, etc. That said though, the biggest common denominator that I have found that determines whether people are glad they did it or not is the attitude and commitment level that they went in with. If you tend to be on the unhappy side here, don't expect that to change there. On the other hand, if you tend to see the bright side here, focus on your locus of control even if its just the size of your pinky, then you wlil fare better there. If you are clear about why you want to do this going in, you will be able to better weather the difficult times. I still think it is one of the best opportunities out there and am consistently amazed that so few Americans don't do it."

    The other thing is it is not like signing up for the military! If it is truly not for you, you can always come back. I think that far more PCVs are glad they did it than aren't. Actually, even if you tend to be on the unhappy side, you should go anyway maybe because it will stretch you like little else and you will make friends and have adventures that you likely won't if you don't take the leap. I had the wackiest host family that are like second family to me and I hope to go back at Christmas time to see them. Connections will be made and friendships that will change who you are.

    Also, people think that you can't turn down an assignment or give a preference- that isn't true. You can't be super picky but it is okay to list your general preferences. For me, I said please don't send me anywhere super hot or that has a lot of mosquitoes and that was totally fine. If a region interests you, it's fine to let them know so long as they know you are still flexible because ultimately they have to match you where your skills set match with theirs.

    People DO have bad experiences and sometimes through no fault of their own but don't let that stop you from going. So many current PCVs are online now that once you get an invitation to a specific country, you could always hop online and find people serving their now or fairly recently and make your most informed decision at that point. If you turn it down, they will likely give you one-two more options.

    Hope that helps!
    Warmest Wishes to you!
    Alex

Recent topics in "Returned Peace Corps Volunteers"